What Does or Should Sharing Look Like in Automated License Plate Reader Systems?

 

What Does or Should Sharing Look Like in Automated License Plate Reader Systems??

Facebook would not be fun if our friends weren't on it. If you weren't connected to family, friends, or neighbors, none of the social media platforms would be of any "value" to us. 

This is the concept of "network effects" -- where the value of a product is based on connections with others using the product. For social media, a key aspect is "social."

Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR) systems have a similar network effects. They become both:

  1. more powerful as a crime-fighting tool;
  2. more questionable as a tool that invades privacy. 
The purpose of this article is to explain why police agencies are attracted to data-sharing within ALPR systems/platforms. And why wide-spread sharing is effective at fighting crime. (It's going to be up to you to argue the opposite side...)

The Chicago metropolitan area is a great example showing the need for shared ALPR data. I know this market well. Chicagoland is an ill-defined region that, depending on where you draw the boundaries, includes:
  • City of Chicago, with a huge Police Department;
  • 275+ suburban municipalities, each with a Police Department;
  • a half-dozen counties, each with a Sheriff's Office;
  • a State Police force; 
  • a few dozen college / university police departments;
  • a handful of railroad police departments.
Criminals traverse the entire metro region in their various crime sprees. Within ten (10) minutes, a criminal can cross through a half-dozen jurisdictions. When inner city criminals venture out into the farther suburbs to commit crimes, they're moving through two (2) or three (3) dozen jurisdictions on their way to and from the scene of the crimes!! No exaggeration. 

And as you may have guessed, these criminals are passing each of these jurisdictions' ALPR cameras. It's not fair to limit any of these single agency detectives to accessing only their own jurisdiction's ALPR data. It's like playing cards with only a portion of the deck. Or putting together a puzzle with only a handful of the jigsaw pieces. 

But the sharing shouldn't stop within a metropolitan area's boundaries. It shouldn't even end at the State border. 

I've held a rather unique combination of assignments as a Police Detective:
  • Burglary task force  - investigating and developing intelligence on organized crews committing home break-ins across the region and the country;
  • Homicide task force - investigating murders across a county;
  • Auto Theft (and Carjacking) work - investigating and interdicting stolen autos by a variety of means;
  • Travelling Crime Groups (AKA: gypsies) - investigating and developing intelligence on organized crews committing a variety of scams, schemes, crimes, ruses, and other across the country.
I mention these experiences because they are diverse. Not just in the crime types, but in how ALPR technology and data is used in each of them. They each require a different set of skills, searches, queries, analytics, alerts, and notifications. The same technology is used differently.... and quite significantly differently in each of these contexts!! Totally different functions and capabilities are used in each of these assignments or roles. Whether you're doing intelligence, surveillance, interdiction, investigation, or other. Same data; different analyses. 

But also, I share these assignments because our successes have all hinged on wide-spread data-sharing. 
  • murderers fleeing the State;
  • travelling crime groups moving across the nation;
  • stolen cars being moved/driven across the country.
Because of data-sharing, we've been able to catch criminals here for other far-away agencies. And far-away agencies have been able to catch our criminals. 

So how does data-sharing work?

Consider Agency A and Agency B, which are two (2) departments who deploy a common vendor ALPR system. They can be adjacent jurisdictions.... or on opposite ends of the country. The tech works the same.
  1. Can Agency A search "reads" or receive data responses from cameras owned and operated by Agency B?
  2. If Agency A has a car "hotlisted" (imported into a system as a vehicle-of-interest that generates an alert), does Agency B receive a "hit" if the car/plate moves into Agency B's jurisdiction and passes a camera?
  3. If Agency A has a car "hotlisted," will Agency A receive a "hit" if the car moves into Agency B's jurisdiction and passes a camera?
These are the big three (3) types of sharing going on within ALPR systems. While each system is slightly different, these basic concepts hold true. In all of them, there is some sort of established relationship between Agency A and Agency B that allow or prevent these things from happening. 

You might ask what percentage of crimes are of this cross-country variety? 

I'll suggest the percentage is small when compared to all crime that occurs within a major metropolitan region. However, I'll also suggest that these are the exact crimes that are being committed by organized, professional, cunning, career criminals. They're going out with the express intention to commit crimes every day, week, or month. It's as if it's their job. 

They've operated at-will across the country, exploiting gaps in intelligence and inter-department communications. It used to be nearly impossible for detectives in Chicagoland to know that a car travelling on our expressways was involved in a robbery in Washington State, or a residential burglary in California, or a car break-in in Indianapolis, or a homicide in New York. Or the opposite -- for us to notify those other regions of criminals that committed crimes here and ventured off on their travels. Yet these are exactly the sorts of significant cases that are being solved or brought to resolution every day across State lines. 

Despite these crime-fighting advantages we have with this technology, there are municipalities within the Chicagoland region that refuse to share their ALPR data. Even with their adjacent neighboring agencies, or with overlapping/concurrent jurisdictions like the County Sheriff or the State Police. Or they refuse to accept alerts from other agency hotlists. To continue with one (1) of my earlier analogies, this does two (2) things:
  1. hold onto puzzle pieces, keeping them away from other regional partners; thereby keeping other detectives from putting together their puzzle;
  2. refuse to accept puzzle pieces from regional partners, keeping themselves isolated from information and data; thereby limiting their own ability to put together their own puzzle.
The vast majority of crime is local. In Chicago, "local" is anywhere within the 275+ municipalities that criminals travel between and through. But some crime, and arguably some of the most intelligent, pre-planned, organized crime, is national. 

Any regulation, policy, or legislation that prevents or restricts ALPR data-sharing is keeping puzzle pieces out of the hands of those working tirelessly to put them together into a coherent picture. And at the risk of allowing otherwise "catch-able" criminals to run free. 

Like I said, there's a counter-argument to be had. You just aren't going to here it from me today. 

***

This is part of a blog series on ALPR systems, specifically thoughts from someone who's maximally used the systems to their fullest capabilities. 

I'm drafting a model policy on how ALPR data could & should be accessed & retained. It's a work in progress. I decided to tip my hand, just a bit, in this post. The policy is more nuanced than this. 

***

Lou Hayes, Jr. is a detective supervisor in a suburban Chicago police department, collaterally detailed to a regional major crimes (homicide) task force.  He has a passion for multi-jurisdictional crime patterns, criminal networks, & regional intelligence. With a background in training, he studies human performance, decision-making, creativity, emotional intelligence, & adaptability. 

Follow Lou on LinkedIn, & also the LinkedIn page for The Illinois Model. ***


Comments

  1. This is an important conversation, especially because it is easy to blur the line between what the law currently requires and what policymakers are proposing for the future.

    Illinois law already places meaningful restrictions on ALPR sharing, including prohibitions involving certain immigration and reproductive-health investigations. But it does not currently impose a blanket prohibition on legitimate law-enforcement sharing across jurisdictions.

    What is particularly relevant to this discussion is SB 3257, currently pending in the Illinois General Assembly. Among other provisions, the bill proposes requiring ALPR detection records to be archived after 90 days, limiting access to older records, and specifically preventing records archived after 90 days from being searchable by out-of-state agencies.

    I think this distinction matters.

    There is a legitimate policy discussion to have around privacy, retention, auditability, appropriate use, and how broadly ALPR information should be shared. We should have it. But we should also be careful not to describe proposed restrictions as existing law or suggest current interagency sharing is inherently improper.

    In many cases, responsible sharing is precisely where LPR provides its greatest public-safety value. A vehicle involved in a violent crime, kidnapping, organized retail theft, or other serious offense does not stop at a city, county, or state line.

    The better question isn’t simply, “Should agencies share?” It is: What should responsible sharing look like?

    Clear purpose. Appropriate permissions. Defined retention. Complete audit trails. Accountability for every search. Restrictions against prohibited uses. And technology designed to give the agency collecting the information control over who can access it.

    SB 3257 is an important part of this conversation, but unless and until it becomes law, it should be discussed for what it is: a proposal for where Illinois policy may go next, not a description of where Illinois law stands today.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment